Black Spot thoughts

Discussion in 'Roses' started by Sandy Ground, Oct 9, 2019.

  1. Sandy Ground

    Sandy Ground Total Gardener

    Joined:
    Jun 10, 2015
    Messages:
    2,268
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    Making things of note.
    Location:
    Scania, Sweden
    Ratings:
    +5,368
    As some of you are aware, part of my garden is a rosarium. This is divided into eight separate beds. Four larger, four smaller. Like many, I have been troubled by Blackspot. As I do not like to use chemicals of any sort, I've treated it in the recommended way. Remove affected leaves both from the plant and ground, and burn. Even so, it usually returned the following year.

    Going back to Autumn 2017, I spread some thuja cuttings as mulch on these borders. During the summer of 2018, I noticed that the black spot did not for once appear. That is despite the fact that summer should have been perfect for it to grow. Hot, dry days, and cool moist nights. A bit of online research came up with the fact that thuja contain what is known as a parasitic fungus that is known to feed of the fungus that causes black spot.

    In Autumn last year, I decided to conduct a small experiment. I again used cuttings on the four larger borders, but omitted to use them on the four smaller ones. The result? None at all on the "treated" borders, but plenty on the untreated ones.

    As I'm currently giving my thuja hedges there Autumn trim, this year I'll treat all of them, just to see if the results are the same.

    A few thoughts occur. How will the annual addition of cuttings affect the ground? My guess is that it will lower the pH. Will this do any harm to the roses? They've been thriving in a pH of 7,5, but is that a normal level?

    I do have some more to add, but will see what our resident experts have to say.
     
    • Like Like x 2
    • Informative Informative x 2
    • noisette47

      noisette47 Total Gardener

      Joined:
      Jan 25, 2013
      Messages:
      5,861
      Gender:
      Female
      Location:
      Lot-et-Garonne, Aquitaine
      Ratings:
      +13,960
      Hi Sandy, not just a change in PH, but I suspect that eventually the soil will become deficient in nitrogen, as the decomposition of woody materiel depletes it.
      You could try sprinkling sulphate of ammonia or pelleted chicken manure around before adding the prunings. I think sulphate of iron will increase the acidity.
       
      • Informative Informative x 2
      • wiseowl

        wiseowl FRIENDLY ADMIN Staff Member

        Joined:
        Oct 29, 2006
        Messages:
        44,112
        Gender:
        Male
        Occupation:
        Philosophy of people
        Location:
        In a barn somewhere in North Kent
        Ratings:
        +89,266
        Good afternoon @Sandy Ground most Roses like a PH of of between 6 and 7,but as I am of the old school rose grower ,my honest opinion is that a good rose will thrive in almost any PH soil if it is cared for correctly. I think that your observations on the Thuja mulch are excellent and they should lower the PH over time as you suggested,but in my limited experience the spores of blackspot can be spread from our clothes,gloves ,splashed and spread by the rain,and remain in the soil all winter,in fact all most any part of us,but please carry on with your experiment I for one will be very interested in your findings my friend,and for what its worth I don't think it will cause any harm to your beautiful Roses my friend:smile::blue thumb:

        A pH of 7.0 is considered neutral. An acid soil has a pH value below 7.0 and above 7.0 the soil is alkaline.
         
        • Like Like x 2
        • Agree Agree x 1
        • Informative Informative x 1
        • Sandy Ground

          Sandy Ground Total Gardener

          Joined:
          Jun 10, 2015
          Messages:
          2,268
          Gender:
          Male
          Occupation:
          Making things of note.
          Location:
          Scania, Sweden
          Ratings:
          +5,368
          @noisette47 I'm not to worried about nitrogen depletion. My local rose breeder supplies me with an 8-3-4 fertiliser that according to him "should be put down when leaves on the birch are as big as the ears on a mouse" and then again after the first bloom period is ended.

          @wiseowl I will keep you informed as to the results, and will be continuing with the experiment. As things stand, I've just finished giving my thuja hedges their "autumn haircut" and have started shredding the cuttings to put on the beds. This year, it will be all of them. I was going to ask if the spores how the spores moved around. Now, I know.

          I did check the pH earlier. Its still 7,5, the same value as in Spring. I'll check again around next Easter.
           
          • Like Like x 1
          • Informative Informative x 1
          • Friendly Friendly x 1
          • lolimac

            lolimac Total Gardener

            Joined:
            Feb 4, 2019
            Messages:
            1,479
            Gender:
            Female
            Location:
            East Riding of Yorkshire
            Ratings:
            +4,927
            This is really interesting @Sandy Ground :thumbsup:...

            I've tried many a way to obliterate Black spot and I notice with my Roses the ones I nurture in my little parterre that get fed and mulched from early spring every 6 weeks give or take ..have flourished where as others dotted around the garden amongst other plants where I can't mulch as much as I'd like do succumb ..the answer is in the mulch as @wiseowl says...it's the spores in the soil around them that do the damage.:dbgrtmb:
             
            • Like Like x 1
            • Agree Agree x 1
            • Friendly Friendly x 1
            • Sandy Ground

              Sandy Ground Total Gardener

              Joined:
              Jun 10, 2015
              Messages:
              2,268
              Gender:
              Male
              Occupation:
              Making things of note.
              Location:
              Scania, Sweden
              Ratings:
              +5,368
              Something that would be interesting is that others that have both thuja and roses in their garden try this and get either the same or a different result. If the same, it would help prove things. If different, why is the result different?

              I've got so many questions about all this now. With luck I should be able to answer them, especially with the help of "GC Power." :)
               
              • Like Like x 3
              • Agree Agree x 1
              • Sheal

                Sheal Total Gardener

                Joined:
                Feb 2, 2011
                Messages:
                35,545
                Gender:
                Female
                Location:
                Beauly, Inverness-shire. Zone 9a
                Ratings:
                +52,310
                It's an interesting idea Sandy, let's hope your experiment with the other rose beds has the same result. :blue thumb: Feeding the roses/soil if necessary will be a lot easier than fighting black spot.
                 
                • Friendly Friendly x 2
                • Agree Agree x 1
                • Mike Allen

                  Mike Allen Total Gardener

                  Joined:
                  Jan 4, 2014
                  Messages:
                  2,861
                  Gender:
                  Male
                  Occupation:
                  Retired. Plant Pathologist.
                  Location:
                  Eltham. SE. London
                  Ratings:
                  +6,097
                  Hello Sandy. May I compliment you upon your experiments and trials. Like you. I am a rosarian in my own rights. Also like you, I have a certain questionable attitude via chemicals in the garden. However as an oldie....long retired, and plant pathologist. I find your contribution very interesting. Personally I'd like to further the intererest with you further. Mike.
                   
                  • Friendly Friendly x 2
                  • Sandy Ground

                    Sandy Ground Total Gardener

                    Joined:
                    Jun 10, 2015
                    Messages:
                    2,268
                    Gender:
                    Male
                    Occupation:
                    Making things of note.
                    Location:
                    Scania, Sweden
                    Ratings:
                    +5,368
                    By all means @Mike Allen I will welcome any and all input.
                     
                  • Oakapple

                    Oakapple Gardener

                    Joined:
                    Feb 4, 2021
                    Messages:
                    104
                    Gender:
                    Female
                    Occupation:
                    Tea and biscuit carrier
                    Location:
                    Oxfordshire UK
                    Ratings:
                    +247
                    In spite of having sandy soil I have no success with roses at all.I have now, as a last resort planted climbing roses from David Austin roses ( expensive!) called Strawberry Hill.Any advice?
                    In the past roses have gone spindly and full of blackspot.
                     
                    • Friendly Friendly x 1
                    • ARMANDII

                      ARMANDII Low Flying Administrator Staff Member

                      Joined:
                      Jan 12, 2019
                      Messages:
                      48,096
                      Gender:
                      Male
                      Ratings:
                      +100,834
                      @
                      Oakapple

                      Rose Strawberry Hill
                      upload_2021-2-5_22-33-56.png
                      @Oakapple

                      Hi Oakapple, well, as most people on GC know, I garden on around 350'-400' feet of pure sand that I've had to slowly improve over the years and I can tell you from experience that Roses, Climbing, Rambling, Shrub, are never really happy in sand. Sandy gardens are fast draining, and nutrient hungry gardens while, just to compound the issue, Roses are hungry plants.
                      So, Roses seem to thrive well in clay and clay loam rather than sandy soil like yours and mine.
                      The only way I've got my Roses to do well is to improve the soil with additions of commercial and/or garden compost, during the growing season feed them at least fortnightly with a High Potash feed such as Tomato Feed.
                      A lot of Modern Roses are bred with disease resistance in mind and I should imagine that since Rose Strawberry Hill was introduced in 2006 it will have some disease resistance. Older Roses, including the "Old Fashioned" Roses are more prone to Black Spot, Rust, etc and even treatment with anti-Fungal Sprays are not the complete answer.
                      As @Mike Allen will tell you one of the ways to try to prevent further disease is to collect the old, yellowing, black spotted leaves, and Bin them......and do not put them on a Compost Heap if you have one.
                      I have around 21 Climbing, Rambling, Shrub Roses, both old fashioned and modern, and Black Spot, Rust infections can differ from year to year. But, if you want to give your Roses the best chance of growing well in your sandy soil, then try to improve your soil as much as possible and, during the growing and flowering period, feed them regularly, at the very least fortnightly, with that High Potash feed such as Tomato Feed.
                       
                      • Friendly Friendly x 1
                      • Mike Allen

                        Mike Allen Total Gardener

                        Joined:
                        Jan 4, 2014
                        Messages:
                        2,861
                        Gender:
                        Male
                        Occupation:
                        Retired. Plant Pathologist.
                        Location:
                        Eltham. SE. London
                        Ratings:
                        +6,097
                        Thanks Amandii for the mention. As many gardeners may have done. Fallen leaves can be a benefit when simply dug in. Over time it became evident that digging in rose leaves, especially in rose beds, that a very noticeable increase of Black Spot often appeared in future seasons. So soil analysis was undertaken and the proof was right there. The problem infection lived on, despite having been buried. So this in a way meant that the rose bush was now planted within it's own supply of the dreaded Black Spot. The rest is history.
                         
                        • Friendly Friendly x 1
                        • Sandy Ground

                          Sandy Ground Total Gardener

                          Joined:
                          Jun 10, 2015
                          Messages:
                          2,268
                          Gender:
                          Male
                          Occupation:
                          Making things of note.
                          Location:
                          Scania, Sweden
                          Ratings:
                          +5,368
                          Starting with black spot. Once upon a time, I did have trouble with this disease. That was depite diligently removing infected leaves, picking those that had fallen up off the ground. Everything, including prunings, was put into black bin bags, and taken to the tip for incineration. It still returned. That, however, was then! Since I started putting down the thuja cuttings, thare has not been any signs of it since! So, in my opinion, that seems to be a cure for it. I do realise though that not everyone has access to thuja cuttings. To that end, I am aware that a company in the Netherlands has developed a liquid based on conifers that is supposed to keep Black Spot at bay. I dont know much about it, other than it has to be used twice a year. Once in Autumn, once in Spring. As things stand, I am under the impression that it cannot be imported to the UK.

                          @ARMANDII like you, I too have light sandy soil. Initially, I was going to disagree with you, as my roses do quite well. Then, I rememembered something. Back in 2006, I installed geothermic heating. The two bores for it were in the area now occupied by my roses. As the area was a mess afterwards, it was levelled off by using copious amounts of compost. I always have more of that than I need in a normal year! It got to 2010 before I planted the roses. Whether or not the compost was still doing any good, I have no idea. Obviously, now that I am giving the rose beds an annual dose of shredded thuja clippings, ie more organic material every year. In conclusion, I would say this. Roses dont need clay soil, just lots and lots of organic material added regularly.
                           
                          • Like Like x 2
                          • Friendly Friendly x 1
                          • ARMANDII

                            ARMANDII Low Flying Administrator Staff Member

                            Joined:
                            Jan 12, 2019
                            Messages:
                            48,096
                            Gender:
                            Male
                            Ratings:
                            +100,834
                            @Sandy Ground

                            Agreed. Sandy. I think my point is that Rose's natural inclination is to grow much better in clay, clay loam rather than sandy soil and, as I pointed out, it takes further improvement of sandy soil, (as both you and I have done), to get Roses to grow and flower well:dunno:
                             
                            • Like Like x 1
                            • Friendly Friendly x 1
                            • Oakapple

                              Oakapple Gardener

                              Joined:
                              Feb 4, 2021
                              Messages:
                              104
                              Gender:
                              Female
                              Occupation:
                              Tea and biscuit carrier
                              Location:
                              Oxfordshire UK
                              Ratings:
                              +247
                              Thank you so much for the very informative replies, I will take up all the suggestions and hope to have a thriving Strawberry Hill rose this year.It’s planted in the ground and being trained up a tripod.I will post a pic of it in Summer.No wonder my roses haven’t done well!No compost and very little feed.The pic of the rose is amazing Armandii, and it’s grown in a pot as well.
                              Mine hasn’t dropped many leaves this Winter, some are green and some are yellow with black spot, I will take off those yellow leaves today and put them to burn.
                              Roses are lovely but do seem to need a lot of time and care, but if SH rose does well, I shall be encouraged to try more.:)
                               
                              • Like Like x 1
                              • Friendly Friendly x 1
                              Loading...

                              Share This Page

                              1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
                                By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
                                Dismiss Notice