Barking mad?

I think we're going to have to agree to disagree on this @noisette47. I'm not convinced that it is either good for the soil or the environment. I have found a good use for it though - as a double layer over the drainage hole in pots, then crocks, then compost. It keeps the compost in the pots and acts as a barrier for slugs and other nasties.

 

I quite agree . Perhaps differences in product, climate and gardening styles all contribute to the rich mix of experiences.

 

I tried it for a short while here on shallow, sandy soil. It caused compaction and dryness. It reminds me of astroturf without the grass .

 

I used membrane last year to grow melons through, so covered the area and just cut crosses where I planted.
It warmed the soil and on sunny days was very warm to the touch, which was the plan to warm up the soil and plant into it.
It kind of worked but as usual the weather was against me and late summer wasn't great.

I'd use it again and amongst planted shrubs with bark on top, it has its uses IMO

 

Despite my concerns around bark chippings and chiggers, I think I will use it again after all. I do think it looks good and it works.

The only other option I was considering was well rotted manure (even though I wasn't sure it would be as effective).

It turns out that one of the dogs, who is on a diet, likes the taste of it. I think I have better chances at fighting invisible chigger larvae, than stopping Frankie from eating. Plus, the issue with chigger larvae lasts about a month. Frankie is hungry all the time.